New York's power play built a lead the rest of their roster couldn't defend, and Buffalo's third-period depth erased it in 13 minutes.
Buffalo's depth scoring suffocated a New York comeback before it could take hold, and a Rangers power play that converted at 66.7% ultimately couldn't compensate for a third period in which they generated nothing. The Atlantic's first seed came to Madison Square Garden and demonstrated exactly why regular-season record translates to playoff readiness.
⚡TURNING POINT
Tuch's 5v5 goal at 5:51 of the third erased the 3-3 tie and immediately shifted the burden of play back onto a Rangers team without the depth to respond. Buffalo had reclaimed the lead at even strength — the one zone where NYR held no structural advantage — and New York never recovered.
🏆WHY BUF WON
•
Buffalo's third period was a 3-0 shutdown: three even-strength goals in 13 minutes from three separate lines demonstrated a depth advantage NYR could not match.
•
Buffalo's penalty kill absorbed four man-down situations and surrendered zero; their 0% power play was irrelevant because NYR's special teams edge never created enough margin.
•
Shot volume (27 vs. 20) and blocked shots (19 vs. 11) reflected territorial dominance that compounded across 60 minutes.
📉WHY NYR LOST
•
New York's second-period lead existed entirely on special teams — both NYR goals came via power play or a single even-strength bounce — with no sustained 5v5 structure to protect it.
•
NYR generated only 20 shots in a game they led entering the third; that output cannot sustain a lead against a team with Buffalo's forward depth.
•
Shesterkin conceded 1.40 goals above average on 27 shots — in a two-goal game, that margin was the difference between a comeback and a blowout.
Three Stars
Jason Zucker1st
BUF, L
1G 1A 2P4 SOG+2
His 4 shots on goal led all skaters and his two-point game contributed directly to the go-ahead sequence in the third.
Ryan McLeod2nd
BUF, C
1G 1A 2P2 SOG+1
McLeod's multi-point output across both the opening and closing periods anchored Buffalo's line connectivity through 60 minutes.
Alexis Lafrenière3rd
NYR, L
2G 0A 2P2 SOG
Both goals kept New York competitive through two periods, but his -2 rating reflects how thoroughly Buffalo's depth overwhelmed that individual production.
